Crate, Gate or Playpen for an Australian Shepherd Puppy?

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Kai-tested means Kai used it, bought with our own money.

Short answer: For an Aussie puppy, I’d start with a crate with a divider for sleep, plus a gate to keep rooms off limits. That’s what we used with Kai.

MidWest iCrate with divider Kai-tested

Kai uses the 42 inch iCrate with a divider. Measure your own dog before choosing a size.

Check Price on Amazon

Kai asleep inside his black wire MidWest iCrate with a white plush toy, blanket over the top

Full review on our iCrate page.

Crate vs gate vs pen, by what you need

We haven’t tested a playpen for this guide, so there’s no playpen recommendation here.

What you needCrate with dividerBaby gatePlaypen
Sleep and nap timeAn enclosed resting space. AKC suggests sizing for adult size with a dividerA barrier across a doorway, not a sleeping spotNot tested for this guide
Keep the pup out of a roomNot its jobThat’s what it’s for. PDSA notes your puppy can still see you through itNot tested for this guide
Gone longer than your pup can manage in a crateDon’t stretch crate time (AKC)AKC mentions a gated kitchen as one optionAKC mentions a playpen as one option
Kai’s house42 inch iCrate36 inch Regalo, hallway and kitchenNot tested for this guide

Pick this if

  • Your pup needs somewhere to sleep and settle: pick the crate. Size it so your puppy can stand up, turn around and lie down comfortably, and use the divider while they grow (AKC).
  • You want whole rooms off limits but your pup near you: pick a gate. Kai’s gates slow the house chaos. They don’t replace training.
  • You’ll be gone longer than your pup can hold it: don’t stretch crate time. AKC suggests a dog sitter or walker, doggy daycare, or a safe puppy proofed space like a playpen or gated kitchen. We haven’t tested a playpen for this guide, so there’s no playpen recommendation here.

Kai’s two setups

Everything below is already on our kit page. Pick the path that matches your day.

Path 1: crate nights

For sleep, naps and short crate time. Start with the iCrate at the top of this page, then add the Snuggle Puppy. Compare crate sizes on our best crate for Australian Shepherd guide.

SmartPetLove Snuggle Puppy Kai-tested

We sent it to the breeder so Kai’s mom’s scent was on it, then it gave him heartbeat comfort for early crate nights. Retire it when they’re past the need.

Check Price on Amazon

Kai lying in his wire crate next to his brown Snuggle Puppy plush

Path 2: gated room days

For keeping the pup in the rooms you choose while you’re home. What we use in the crate and on gate days is on our kit page. More on gates on our best puppy gates guide.

Regalo Easy Step Extra Tall gate Kai-tested

Kai’s doorways have these, the same 36 inch Regalo, hallway and kitchen. It slows the house chaos. It doesn’t replace training.

Check Price on Amazon

Kai as a red merle puppy sitting behind our white Regalo walk thru gate

What vets and welfare groups say

The RSPCA is clear that a crate should never be used as punishment, and suggests putting safe chew toys inside. AKC says to skip the crate if it stresses your dog, and to watch for things like pacing, scratching at the door, long barking or drooling. Even in a puppy proofed house, AKC says a new puppy shouldn’t be left unsupervised.

Take the collar off for crate time. VCA Animal Hospitals warns a collar can get tangled and twisted tight in a crate or kennel. On timing, Best Friends Animal Society suggests puppies not be crated more than two to three hours, but your vet knows your puppy best.

No crate, gate or pen is a promise your pup stays put. Every puppy is different, so measure your own dog and watch how they handle it.

Common questions

Should I get a crate, a gate or a playpen for an Aussie puppy?

Pick by the job. A crate is an enclosed resting space for sleep and short crate time. A gate is a barrier that keeps a puppy out of certain rooms while they can still see you. AKC mentions a playpen or a gated kitchen as options when you’ll be gone longer than your dog can manage in a crate. We haven’t tested a playpen for this guide, so there’s no playpen recommendation here.

What size crate does an Australian Shepherd puppy need?

AKC says the crate should let your puppy stand up, turn around and lie down comfortably, and suggests buying for adult size with a divider so it grows with your dog. Kai’s crate is the 42 inch MidWest iCrate. That’s his setup, not a size rule for every Aussie, so measure your own dog.

How long can I leave my Aussie puppy in a crate?

There isn’t one number for every puppy. AKC says not to crate a dog longer than they’re comfortable or can hold their bladder, or at all if it causes stress or panic. Best Friends Animal Society suggests no more than two to three hours for puppies. Ask your vet about yours.

Is there a gate height that works for every Aussie?

No. We don’t know of any authority that gives one safe height for every dog, and a gate isn’t a guarantee your pup stays put. Kai’s doorways have 36 inch Regalo gates. Watch your own puppy and ask your vet or trainer.

Should my puppy wear a collar in the crate?

VCA Animal Hospitals warns that a collar can get tangled and twisted tight, and lists a crate or kennel as one place it can happen. VCA also says dogs should be supervised when wearing collars and harnesses.

Still deciding? See how to crate train your Australian Shepherd puppy or everything Kai uses on the kit page.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top